Is that a tantrum? Again?

Published On: 15-Oct-2018

In April this year I wrote that investing in equities had a lot in common with parenting. The market is volatile and it will throw a tantrum every now and then. And you will have to deal with it just as you deal with the tantrums of a child or a teen. Being both a parent and an investor I see the similarities. I also see the difference. Most children eventually move on from the tantrums as they mature and grow older. But the market– it will always remain a teenager. Frequent tantrums are the nature of the market.

In my earlier piece I said the following

“Gains (in equities) do not accrue in a linear fashion. I believe these facts are important and should be highlighted to all investors, particularly the surge of investors who are making their way into the markets. In the long term the stock market is a slave to earnings. But in the short term it resembles the outcomes of a voting machine more than it does a weighing machine which is calibrated for consistency. Economic cycles, evolving and changing businesses combined with the emotions of greed and fear create sharp moves in both directions in the market”

Let’s look at the updated table of monthly performance of the markets (updated as of 0ctober 08, 2018). The table below depicts the monthly performance of the Nifty over time. The final column on the right depicts the annual performance of the Nifty. As you can see the outcomes are not linear – the compounded average annual return over the period is vastly different from the actual calendar year performance of the market.

Monthly Performance of Stock Market

In the 286 months above the market has fallen in 126 months, in other words in 44% of the months the Nifty has dropped. The worst monthly fall has been ~20%. In 11 months out of 286 it has fallen between 10%-20%. Over this period (Jan ’95 to Oct ’18) the point to point CAGR return is 9.55%. It is the nature of the market to be volatile and throw tantrums.A monthly SIP investor comes out much better at 11.95% CAGR excluding dividends.

CAGR – Compounded Annualised Growth Rate

In February & March of this year the mood swing was said to be caused by the imposition of Long Term Capital Gains tax, worries about earnings and global weakness. In recent days we are told it is to do with worries about emerging financial fragilities in India, rising oil prices and a falling currency. But remember this: the market never speaks-so everything you read about why it went up or down is merely that person’s interpretation of events. It may say more about them than it does about the market. The markets are influenced by multiple factors and millions of market participants.

We believe that the stock market is a slave to earnings i.e. long term returns tend toward long term earnings growth. But there are periods during which investors willingly pay more for equities and periods during which they choose to pay less. This mood swing of investors has a lot to do with the emotions of greed and fear. Investor confidence tends to move higher when markets move higher and confidence turns down when markets move lower. Equities rarely trade at fair value instead they tend to move in cycles from low to high and then back down again. We can’t predict when or why it happens but history tells us that we should expect and prepare for this.

The fluctuations resemble what we call in science the sinusoidal wave or the sine wave. The below image depicts what a sine wave looks like. Further below thatis what the P/Evaluation wave looks like. Not as neatly patterned but the broad form is similar. Unlike the predictable rhythm of the sine wave the moves in the valuation wave are far more jagged and do not follow a specific time rhythm.

So what can we say about the market at this time. The chart below depicts the trailing 12-month P/Evaluation for the Sensex. It has dropped though not so sharply so as to drop it tothe dark green zone (cheap). Note that the oscillations of the valuation wave on its way down often falls short of the dark green(cheap) zone. Just as, on the way up, the moves may halt well below the orange zone(expensive).The important takeaway is that valuations have and will continue to oscillate.Why, when and how much are impossible to know beforehand.Knowing that there is valuation risk in the market,as Fund Managers we try to manage this by picking stocks where there is some valuation comfort or where we have conviction in the longer term growth prospects. That can hopefully allow us to navigate the volatility much better.

Trailing 12-month P/E valuation for the Sensex


The chart below depicts the forward 12-month (consensus estimates) P/E valuation for the Sensex. This data is for a shorter period of 10 years vs the 20 year period for trailing valuations. This metric has dropped to the light green zone (fairly valued zone); the lowest it has been since late 2016. This signifies that some value has now emerged in the market. The caveat here is that in recent years the forecasts have always proved too optimistic.


Forward 12-month P/E valuation for the Sensex

Midcap valuations that were at a premium to large caps have compressed the gap as can be seen below.

Forward P/E of Nifty 50 and Midcap Index

The table below presents the change in the indices over 1 year and also from their 52 week high. As you move down the market cap curve –from large to mid and then small the damage increases.

Source: Bloomberg, as of 8th Oct 2018

The table below shows the drawdown experienced by companies in the BSE 500 index. This is arranged by the market cap rank of the company and the extent of fall. This again highlights that there has been significant damage as you move down along the market cap curve. Looking at the extent of this damage we think it very likely that some good businesses may have been trampled upon along with their weaker cousins. So even as fear has increased a few notches the data tells us that opportunities are emerging.


Source: Bloomberg, as of 8th Oct 2018

In conclusion, the selloff in recent weeks, as nerve wracking as it has been for investors, is not out of sync with historical volatility of the markets. Forward valuations are now in the upper reaches of the fairly valued zone. Not yet cheap but not expensive either. The market is throwing a tantrum. Euphoria (Greed)& Tantrums (Fear) create the oscillations that we see in the valuation wave. An investor following a SIP approach should not fear this – the underlying principle of the SIP is to invest at all valuations thereby dampening the impact of valuations over time. Equities are a volatile asset class with attractive long term returns. In order to ride out the market tantrums investors should incorporate valuations into their asset allocation strategy based on their financial goals.


Mutual Fund investments are subject to market risks, read all scheme related documents carefully.

Author Bio

Vetri Subramaniam
Vetri Subramaniam is Group President & Head of Equity at UTI Asset Management Company Ltd. He has been in this role since January 2017. UTI MF manages assets of Rs. 1,717 bn* and the total assets under management of UTI are Rs. 10,981 bn*. At UTI MF Vetri leads a team of 19 persons including analysts and fund managers. The total equity assets managed and advised by the team are Rs. 1,077 bn*. Vetri has over 26 years of work experience. Prior to joining UTI in January 2017 he was Chief Investment Officer at Invesco Asset Management Ltd. He was part of the start-up team at Invesco (then Religare Asset Management) in 2008 and helped establish the firm¬タルs proprietary investment process and the team. During this period the firm established a strong track record. The firm also launched several offshore funds investing into India from Japan, Mauritius & Luxembourg. Vetri started his career at Kotak Mahindra in 1992 after passing out from IIM Bangalore with a PG Diploma in Management. His experience in equity markets & investment roles at various firms from 1994 includes Kotak Mahindra, SSKI & Motilal Oswal. He was also one of the founders of (now Sharekhan BNP Paribas) where he led the research & content team. He has also worked as an advisor to a UK Hedge fund Boyer Allan on its equity investments in India during 2003-2007. He is a frequent contributor to the media and regularly speaks on equities and investing at various forums - including the media & educational institutions. *The Month end AUM figures are as of December 31, 2020.